The Evening: Justices consider a religious charter school
Also, The Times examined Trump’s deportation deal with El Salvador.
The Evening

April 30, 2025

Good evening. Here’s the latest at the end of Wednesday.

  • A case on state-funded religious schools
  • Behind Trump’s deportation deal
  • Plus, a kangaroo on the loose
The Supreme Court covered in scaffolding. Purple and yellow flowers are in the foreground.
Eric Lee/The New York Times

Justices seemed open to backing a religious charter school

The Supreme Court appeared open today to allowing Oklahoma to use government money to run the nation’s first religious charter school. A decision in favor of the school could lead to the opening of similar institutions across the country and lower the wall separating church and state.

The main question in the case is whether the First Amendment permits states to sponsor and finance religious charter schools. In other words, the Supreme Court is deciding whether charter schools, which are publicly funded and privately run, are fundamentally public or private.

During arguments today, the court’s conservative justices were largely sympathetic to the school, while the liberal ones were quite wary. However, Justice Amy Coney Barrett recused herself from the case without explanation. That left the court’s chief justice, John Roberts, with the likely deciding vote. He was less pointed than the other Republican appointees but still expressed doubt that religious charter schools were different from other groups the court had protected from discrimination.

The case is one of the most significant of the term, so the court will probably not issue a decision until late June or early July.

For more: The school at the heart of the case, St. Isidore of Seville Catholic Virtual School, is named for the patron saint of the internet. If the Supreme Court permits it to proceed, it would open as an online school.

Exterior view of a prison tower and fence with razor wire.
The prison in Tecoluca, El Salvador, where Kilmar Armando Abrego Garcia is being held. Jose Cabezas/Reuters

A look behind Trump’s migrant deal with El Salvador

The Trump administration recently sent a letter to officials in El Salvador requesting the return of a migrant who had been wrongly deported. Salvadoran officials, according to people with knowledge of the matter, said no. It was unclear, however, whether it was a genuine effort or window dressing to appear in compliance with a Supreme Court ruling.

President Trump acknowledged in an interview yesterday that he could free the man, Kilmar Armando Abrego Garcia, but that he wouldn’t because he believed he was a gang member.

Last month, El Salvador’s president, Nayib Bukele, had expressed concerns about the deportations. He asked U.S. officials for assurances that the men were all gang members, causing the Americans to scramble to get him evidence. The incident raised questions about whether the Trump administration had sufficiently assessed those it had dispatched to a foreign prison.

My colleagues learned of Bukele’s concerns when they went back and reconstructed the deal between Trump and El Salvador. Here are takeaways from their investigation, as well as an hour-by-hour timeline of the deportations.

In other politics news:

A grocery store worker stands at a cash register while someone picks up a package of food.
Mark Abramson for The New York Times

Tariff fears caused the G.D.P. to sink

Data released today on U.S. gross domestic product suggested that the economy shrank in the first quarter by a 0.3 percent annual rate, following strong growth at the end of last year.

The decline, however, was somewhat misleading. Underlying economic growth remained solid, and the G.D.P. drop was driven almost entirely by a huge increase in imports as consumers and businesses rushed to buy goods and materials before Trump’s tariffs took effect. But tariffs and uncertainty have increased in the last month, prompting economists to warn that growth could continue to slow.

In related news, stocks performed worse in Trump’s first 100 days compared with how they did at the start of every presidential term since 1974.

A school bus during severe weather. Cars with their beams reflected on the wet pavement are approaching on a narrow road.
Students left school in McDonald, Pa., during the storm yesterday.  Lucy Schaly/The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, via Associated Press

A deadly storm tore through Pennsylvania

Hundreds of thousands of people in Pennsylvania were still without power this afternoon after a powerful storm plowed through the area yesterday. At least four people were killed, including a 22-year-old man who was electrocuted while trying to put out a mulch fire.

More top news

TIME TO UNWIND

A man holds a plate with a pastry as three others look on.
Benjamin Voisin, left, as Marie-Antoine Carême. Apple TV+

A steamy TV show about the father of French gastronomy

Marie-Antoine Carême is widely thought to be one of the world’s first celebrity chefs. During the early 19th century, he served kings, invented the croquembouche and coined the phrase “You can try this yourself at home.” Now, Carême is the subject of an Apple TV+ series that premieres today.

The show, like many period dramas, has a loose relationship to historical facts. But that frees it to be spry and fun, our critic writes.

A ballerina with a cappuccino cup for a head dances.

Meet Ballerina Cappuccina

Her head is a cup. She is the wife of Cappuccino Assassino. And she’s incredibly famous.

For those of you who have never heard of Ballerina Cappuccina, don’t worry. Neither had I. She is the star of the incredibly popular, and intentionally silly, internet trend called Italian brain rot. On TikTok, she and her other A.I.-generated friends — like Bombardiro Crocodilo — have generated over three billion views.

Two children stand by a helicopter on the ground. A person takes a picture of one of the children.
The war remnants museum in Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam. Hannah Reyes Morales for The New York Times

Dinner table topics

WHAT TO DO TONIGHT

A French lentil salad with carrots on a plate.
Linda Xiao for The New York Times

Cook: This French lentil salad is hearty, friendly and bright with flavor.