Email Template
 
 
 
The Chronicle of Higher Education Logo - When a College Closes
Insights on Higher Ed's Future
 
 
 
 
 
 

I have the pleasure of covering political groups, agendas, and actors for The Chronicle. I’m perpetually interested in how big ideas about education and society get interpreted through the small decisions made daily on a college campus. And there’s perhaps no campus better suited to refracting those ideas than New College of Florida, in Sarasota.

 
 
 
The College That Conservatives Took Over
 
 
In 2023, Ron DeSantis, Florida’s Republican governor, announced he was overhauling New College’s Board of Trustees. Traditionally, the college, which at that point had less than 700 students, was known for its lefty views and social-justice bonafides, its lack of letter grades, and its embrace of the quirky.
 
 
 
 
 
Now, that same institution would be managed by conservatives who thought very differently about what values the college should embody. The most prominent trustee, Christopher F. Rufo, has crusaded against critical race theory and diversity, equity, and inclusion efforts.

After DeSantis announced his appointments, critics predicted the worst.  In their eyes, the college’s new leadership would demolish a liberal-arts jewel in service of a political goal. Meanwhile, supporters of DeSantis cast New College as the first battle in the war against higher ed’s ideological capture.

I’m skeptical of easy narratives. So I spoke with all sorts of people — among them current and former professors, staff members, students, alumni — to get a clearer view of what New College was actually like before the takeover and what it’s been like after.

 
 
 
 
 
 

Some are true believers in the “new” New College. Some severely doubt that effort and attempt to resist it. And some find themselves in the middle, appreciating certain aspects of the transformation, like the increase in state dollars and that enrollment is trending upward, but worrying about others, like the killing off of the gender-studies program.

What emerged from my reporting is a portrait of a campus in fluxThat portrait, I think, is all the more relevant considering the Trump administration’s efforts to bring higher ed to heel during his first 100 days in office. 

While the board shakeup at New College might seem quaint by comparison, the ideas that animated it are the same ones en vogue in the White House: chiefly, that colleges across the country have too long been captured by Democrats and leftists at the expense of academic achievement, and drastic measures must be taken to right the ship. 

My article is an  examination of how that criticism has manifested on one tiny campus on Florida’s western coast. 

As I continue to cover politics in academe, here are a few questions that I’m thinking about:

 
 
 
 
In these polarized times, are there conservative critiques that liberal readers think have validity? Or vice versa?
 
 
 
 
Why has higher ed bled support with the public, and to what degree did colleges and universities make themselves a soft target?
 
 
 
 
Tactically, what stance would you like your college leaders to take should the Trump administration come knocking?
 
 
 
 

Let me know your thoughts on those questions and if there are others you think I should be asking. I’d love to hear from you. You can reach me at emma.pettit@chronicle.com

Sincerely, 

Emma Pettit
Senior Reporter

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
The Chronicle of Higher Education Logo   ©The Chronicle. All Rights Reserved.
 
 
 

Twitter
   LinkedIn   Facebook   YouTube