Opinion Today: How to save American democracy
The 1920s proves that though we’re on a dangerous path, the country’s fate has not been sealed.
Opinion Today
October 6, 2025

By Michael Agger

Senior Staff Editor, Opinion Features

We’ve been here before. An America with a cresting wave of political violence. An America divided by staggering inequality. An America that has shut the door on immigrants from “undesirable” countries. An America in the grip of a disinformation crisis. An America that puts people in jail for speaking out.

This was the United States of the 1920s. But as the historian John Fabian Witt writes in a guest essay for Times Opinion, “America’s dangerous decade led not to fascism and the end of democracy but to the New Deal and the civil rights era.” What did it take to pull America back from the brink?

Our democratic renewal sprang from an unlikely source: a handsome Harvard dropout who gave away his million-dollar inheritance. That man was Charles Garland, and his money, in the form of one of the first nonprofit foundations of the modern tax code, would supercharge a new generation of reformers. Why were they so effective? And how can we follow their example today?

Read more:

Here’s what we’re focusing on today:

Editors’ Picks

An illustration depicting a padlock against an orange background. The shackle is shaped like the outline of the Capitol rotunda.

Frank Bruni

Trump’s Shutdown Glee Could Come Back to Bite Him

Republicans’ exploitation of government’s closure is the tell that they prefer it this way.

By Frank Bruni

More From Opinion

The Opinions

Trumpism After Trump: The Future of the Right

A conservative’s vision for MAGA beyond Trump.

play button

30 MIN LISTEN

A photograph of hands reaching for one another.

David French

There’s a Path Out of This Divide

There’s a way out of this, and people in despair are leading the way.

By David French

An illustration shows George Bachiashvili standing in a cell, with the face of Bidzina Ivanishvili looming largely behind him.

Guest Essay

Someone Tipped Me Off About a Crypto Story. What I Found Was Crazy.

The souring of the relationship between Georgia’s billionaire master and his former aide is a cautionary tale.

By Philip Shishkin

A photograph of President Trump smiling and waving before an audience, blurred in the foreground. Some of the audience members appear to be wearing red hats.

Jamelle Bouie

Who Is Donald Trump Responsible To?

Trump’s exclusionary view of the country strains the bonds of union.

By Jamelle Bouie

A woman, in black and white, with her face pixelated.

Maureen Dowd

When A.I. Came for Hollywood

The Dream Factory is going full fantasy, human factor be damned.

By Maureen Dowd

Guest Essay

They Have Waited Two Years for the Hostages. These Are Their Rituals.

Families of captives in Gaza find private ways to stay connected to their loved ones.

By Ofir Berman and Sarah Wildman

Ross Douthat

Why Left and Right Can’t Understand Each Other’s Fears

Getting past the urge to reduce all politics to existential conflict.

By Ross Douthat

People in various states of undress in a park.

Nicholas Kristof

Mr. President, May We Interest You in a Naked Bike Ride?

Trump’s dispatch of National Guard troops to Portland is another dangerous step toward politicizing America’s military forces.

By Nicholas Kristof

A photo illustration of the facade of the Supreme Court building revealing a blueprint with the word “Equal” on it.

Guest Essay

The Origin of ‘Equal Justice Under Law'

The phrase doesn’t appear in the Constitution or its amendments.

By Anthony Kennedy

A color photo illustration shows a crumbling brick wall held together with shiny, silver glue.

Guest Essay

There Are Two Economies: A.I. and Everything Else

This is worse than putting all your eggs in one basket.

By Natasha Sarin

A view of an empty examining room.

Guest Essay

G.O.P. to Gen Z: Pay Double for Health Insurance or Go Without

If Democrats don’t win the shutdown fight, millions of young Americans may lose coverage because of higher prices.

By Natalie Foster

A photo of a house behind tall grass with a cloudy sky above.

Guest Essay

The West Is Lost

Loss has become a pervasive condition of life in Europe and America.

By Andreas Reckwitz

Guest Essay

How to Save a Book Festival

With humanities funding vanishing, stories and those who protect them remain our greatest hope.

By Margaret Renkl

Zohran Mamdani, in a black-and-white photo taken from a low angle, stands in a New York street.

Guest Essay

Stopping Zohran Mamdani Won’t Save the Political Old Guard

Dismissing candidates like Zohran Mamdani simply because of their youth is no longer viable. Millennial and Gen Z Americans will only gain more political influence.

By Jennifer Steinhauer

Guest Essay

The N.F.L. Gets It. Why Don’t Democrats?

The Democrats need to understand that woke can be good business.

By Molly Jong-Fast

An illustration of a woman onstage squinting to see her young fans

Guest Essay

Sudden Pop Stardom After 50

My song went viral on TikTok, and then I was touring the world.

By Concetta Kirschner

A photograph of a neon cross, reflected five times in surrounding mirrors.

Guest Essay

Students in Texas Need Something, but It’s Not the Ten Commandments

What exactly is religion, anyway?

By Kwame Anthony Appiah

Guest Essay

The Chaos of Driving in Lebanon Tells a Story of a Country Unraveled

Lebanon’s traffic nightmare paints a portrait of a nation verging on collapse.

By Nada Bakri

Two men in suits shake hands. Between their hands, thorns grow.

Illustration by Sam Whitney/The New York Times

letters

Civility and Disagreement in American Politics

Readers respond to a guest essay by Roxane Gay. Also: A Canadian’s lament.

We hope you’ve enjoyed this newsletter, which is made possible through subscriber support. Subscribe to The New York Times.

Games Here are today’s Mini Crossword, Wordle and Spelling Bee. If you’re in the mood to play more, find